On why animal rights groups aren’t hitting the mark.

9 Jan

Edit: I’ve removed a few paragraphs. I forgot it’s only okay to tease gingers.

I would be considered by lots of people in my hometown to be a “fag loving, lefty communist”. I am a pretty typical liberal 26 year old. (Please note, I mean liberal in the actual sense of the word, not the political party.) However when it comes to causes, I am what I would call a “casual protester”. This shouldn’t be interpreted to mean that I only have a casual interest in particular causes, instead that I am unwilling to align myself with many organisations and as a result this has lead to a sketchy attendance record for protests, including those related to issues that I hold strong opinions on. If I had a protest report card it would probably read :

“Angela would benefit from more regular attendance. If she concentrated half as much on the presented material as she does socialising with other protesters, she could go far. Does not apply herself, ie has never made or carried a sign.”

I went to this one. It rained.

My concern is not with the issues themselves, rather the method in which groups choose to make their point. Currently, I am most infuriated with a couple of animal rights groups. I am reaching saturation point with these groups, probably because of their attack campaigns over Christmas.

Don’t get me wrong, I agree with almost all of their points. It’s the tactics and angles I have a real issue with, and I really think their approaches are disadvantageous to their cause. Do I think that animal rights might be in a far better state if smarter tactics were deployed? Yes, I think they probably would be.

So what am I talking about? Well, for example encouraging the general public to become vegan is like asking them for a million bucks when you’d be lucky to score ten dollars. Realistically, the vast majority of people are never going to become vegan, and by making unreasonable requests you are at the same time labeling yourself an unreasonable group.

Some Babe-on-Babe action.

Baby steps are required for real change. Many of these organisations have very dedicated (if not occasionally misguided and overzealous) members, as well as quite substantial funding. Imagine if every dollar and every man hour spent on encouraging a very unwilling majority was redirected and used to educate the public on how to shop for organic and cruelty free food? Encouraging people to buy free range bacon is a completely reasonable and achievable goal. Once you’ve conquered that mountain, then perhaps try for Meat Free Mondays.

You’ve got to get kids to eat vegetables by offering them a few peas at a time. You don’t lock them in a Birds Eye processing plant and expect them to come out the other side thanking you for showing them the light. By aiming too high, these groups are missing the majority of their audience on the way up. Tell me how to shop for organic food, I’ll listen. Tell me to stop eating meat, I’ll tell you to eat shit that I hear what you’re saying, and I respect your opinion. But no.

This meal is bullshit.

My other issue with animal rights groups is the misdirection of their protests. For example, as far as I am aware (and correct me if I am wrong) but the majority, if not all, pet shop owners have zero law making power. They aren’t running pet shops during the day and banning semi-automatic weapons by night. So why are animal rights groups protesting at pet shops?

Well, we know why they are protesting. They are protesting the sale of farmed domestic pets and inhumane conditions in the shops themselves. However that isn’t what the average Joe see’s when confronted with a group of pamphlet waving, dread sporting hippies in front of a shop. He see’s an attack on small business, and a group of self righteous lefty wankers making a scene.

Pet shops aren’t going to cease the sale of farmed animals because an animal rights group picketed their shop and handed out leaflet after leaflet to an unwilling public (leaflets that are destined to end up on the ground around the corner, but that’s another issue). They will stop, however, when the law says they have to stop. So instead of picketing, what could they do? How do you draw attention to an issue that no-one cares about?

Oh wait, that’s right. Everyone cares because everyone fucking loves puppies and kitties. How do I know that everyone loses their shit over the small furry variety of cute?

Oh, that's right.

So how do you reach an audience and educate them on an issue that can be illustrated with lolcats? Well for starters, you don’t alienate your audience, and that is what happens with these protests. Instead, get your most straightlaced and well spoken representative, put him in a suit and make friends with some journalists. Do a press conference somewhere appropriate, like outside a pet shop parliament house. Turn yourself into a group that your friendly MP can actually side with, rather than one they will cross the street to avoid.

Also, cut these off. It's over.

So many of the people that volunteer their time and donate their money to these groups have a level of dedication that I can only imagine possessing, but it’s being wasted by badly organised and badly conceived campaigns. If you’ve ever NOT gone to a protest, not because you didn’t strongly support the cause, but because you didn’t want to be associated with the organisers, then you understand what I’m saying.

Uh, that's okay guys. You go on ahead without me.

Now I already know that a lot of people aren’t going to agree with any of this, and the kind of abusive comments I am expecting are what make the internet go around. But please, at least consider cutting off the dreads. I know I’m right about that bit.

Oh, yummers!

Last thing: Why is it veg-etarian but ve-gan? Why isn’t it pronounced veg-an? This is a serious question.

One Response to “On why animal rights groups aren’t hitting the mark.”

  1. The other Tom January 9, 2011 at 9:39 pm #

    A+

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.